Apparent Departures from the Application of Principles of Islamic Legal Theory in al-Zarkashi's Commentary on Mukhtasar al-Khiraqi: Command and Prohibition

Authors

  • Nawf bint Sulayman bin 'Abd al-Rahman al-'Adl المؤلف

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.63312/2439-004-008-007

Keywords:

Departure ('Udul), Consistent Application (Ittirad), Non-Application of a Principle, Al-Zarkashi, Principle of Islamic Legal Theory

Abstract

  • Research Subject: This study examines instances in which some Hanbali jurists depart, in their substantive legal rulings, from the implications of principles of Islamic legal theory concerning command and prohibition. These include both departures from the predominant transmitted position and instances in which the predominant transmitted position itself departs from an established legal-theoretical principle.

  • Methodology: The study uses non-exhaustive induction, selecting legal cases that represent different reasons for departure within the scope of the research. Its purpose is to demonstrate an analytical approach to these reasons. It examines the basis of each transmitted position and, within the material available, the type of evidence or consideration that led its proponents to depart from the principle's apparent implication (sarif).

  • Objective: To explain why a substantive legal ruling may depart from the implications of a principle of Islamic legal theory and to distinguish genuine departures from differences in how the principle is applied to a particular case.

  • Results: Principles of Islamic legal theory are presumed to apply consistently, and departure from the authoritative formulation of a principle requires a valid justification. The cases examined reveal four reasons for departure: an external contextual indication (qarinah munfasilah); conflict between principles; consideration of interests (masalih), objectives (maqasid), and the effective cause of the ruling ('illah); and failure of the particular case to satisfy the conditions for applying the principle. Much of what is regarded as departure is in fact disagreement over whether the grounds for applying a ruling are present in a particular case (tahqiq manat al-hukm).

  • Recommendations: The study recommends collecting and examining the reasons for departing from the predominant transmitted position as a method of weighing and preferring juristic positions (tarjih). It also recommends a comparative analytical study of the reasons for departure to establish principles and criteria for distinguishing justified departures from unjustified ones.

 

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Published

2026-11-17

Issue

Section

البحوث والدراسات

How to Cite

Apparent Departures from the Application of Principles of Islamic Legal Theory in al-Zarkashi’s Commentary on Mukhtasar al-Khiraqi: Command and Prohibition. (2026). مجلة الفقه الحنبلي وأصوله, 8. https://doi.org/10.63312/2439-004-008-007

Similar Articles

1-10 of 77

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.